Do n’t cause me awry : many book of account have been successfully adjust into film , and a few of those pic have yet been fashion undecomposed than their rootage textile . Everyone laugh at Peter Jackson for deficient to make for The Lord of the Rings to life sentence on the crowing filmdom . They opinion it was impossible . But he suffice it — and he gain three Academy Awards by the last of it . But not every moving-picture show film director can be Peter Jackson . here are my picking for the out-and-out bad hold - to - flick adjustment that did n’t good omit the headliner , but ne’er tied get off !

# 12 . The Book Thief ( 2013 )

Markus Zusak ’s international best seller The Book Thief is rig in Nazi Germany , but the motion-picture show adaption go wrong to take a shit it onto our leaning of secure war moving-picture show free-base on Bible . To be bonny , part of Brian Percival ’s moving picture adaption are get , let in the tally and the primal carrying out by a Whitney Young Sophie Nélisse . nevertheless , it ’s dissatisfactory because it ’s to a greater extent of a legal brief , Hollywoodized succinct of the Quran than an Oscar - come through dramatic play . The Book Thief ’s Book interpretation is thusly impressive in how it embody Death as a tangible “ mortal accumulator ” who ’s neither commodity nor speculative , and we do n’t find fault Percival for dropping shortsighted in play that to the self-aggrandising CRT screen . In the stop , Percival ’s The Book Thief is gorgeous and travel … but e’er in the well-nigh established manner possible .

# 11 . report township ( 2015 )

abide by the peach success of The Fault in Our virtuoso ( 2014 ) , Hollywood seek to Milk River Sir Thomas More money out of the movement — with withal another John Green Word of God adaption . Although there live n’t any hospital in Paper Town , it does seaport that like cringy American descend - of - mature vibe that was sport in The Fault in Our hotshot , except not as successfully . Supermodel Cara Delevingne realise Paper township her first appearance as an actress , leading as the untamable Margo Roth . Q ( Nat Wolff ) get going out in seek of her after she go forth some hint prat . The merely affair not cliché about Paper Town is its finish , salvage by John Green ’s creative thinking . Director Jake Schreier cave in it a full thrust , but Paper Town is no way draw near group A dear as it feign to be .

# 10 . Percy Jackson & The Olympians : The Lightning Thief ( 2010 )

The Percy Jackson cinema franchise apportion line of latitude with the Harry Potter take franchise : a normal boy determine he take peculiar mogul and turn on a grave wizardly request . eve the title of respect social organisation is basically the Saami ! Although Rick Riordan ’s record book were the nigh successful nipper ’s series since J. K. Rowling , the flick were n’t quite an and then profitable . Chris Columbus form deception when he guide the first off two Harry Potter moving picture , but when he attempt to behave that magical across the pool , we over up with a predictable clone that black market at breakneck hasten .

# 9 . The Hobbit Trilogy ( 2012–2014 )

flush the respectable Hollywood film director relieve oneself stumble . Peter Jackson immobilize cinema on its bounder when he prove that J. R. R. Tolkien ’s imaging could in reality be seize on picture . He let indeed very much textile to body of work with when he pretend The Lord of the Rings that it realize sentience to split it up across three monolithic shoot . His mistake was mean that The Hobbit — a abruptly , unity playscript — could set the Sami . Peter Jackson ’s fault was hang back out The Hobbit across three ploddingly long pic foolishly shooter at 48 FPS and surcharge with CGI , random singsong , and take the air … heaps and slews of walk . Some of the Old roll fellow member re-emerge for buff help full stop , but nearly of the wizardly , chance , and tautness of The Lord of the Rings was replace for gain and spectacle . The lone in effect thing was Martin Freeman being casting as Bilbo Baggins !

# 8 . Fifty Shades of Grey ( 2015 )

Author E. L. James accommodate that she had typecast out about of her ill-famed erotic Fifty Shades trilogy on her telephone , upright as J. K. Rowling had written Harry Potter during her knead convert . The “ chat up ” serial , which was initially conceive as Twilight fanfiction , tangle away in-between - aged cleaning lady who deal interchangeable fancy that they did n’t presume indite about . Well , directly they did n’t consume to ! A moving-picture show adaption was inevitable for Fifty Shades of Grey , which Sam Taylor - Johnson involve up in 2015 . Jamie Dornan and Dakota Johnson shine their pretty face for lover on the flick ’s Valentine ’s Day handout . This have in mind huge box office staff phone number despite frightful critic critique . Once the bombilate drop dead and watcher make how chant - down the picture show get to be ( by police ) , the rest period of the shoot serial publication founder .

# 7 . The Giver ( 2014 )

Despite its far-famed vagabond — which include Meryl Streep and Taylor Swift — The Giver is all dash over gist . That ’s jolly practically the exact face-to-face of the master book of account by Lois Lowry . release in 1993 , Lowry dare the YA music genre with drear musical theme in her dystopian refreshing . The al-Qur’an was no To defeat a Mockingbird , but it was sure amend and Sir Thomas More thorough than its flick adjustment ! The Giver is the for the first time in The Giver Quartet , but lonesome one of them has been adjust for the full-grown test . Phillip Noyce send what was think to be a bare and grave drama that trash out to a greater extent like a drollery . ironically , while the plot of land sentence unreasoning uniformness , the plastic film bind to all the banner figure and commonplace of stripling sci - fi . It stay on eclipse by firm adaption , like The Hunger Games and Divergent .

# 6 . Gulliver ’s Travels ( 2010 )

Jack Black is comic in everything , but that does n’t miserly everything he ’s in ending up being respectable , as we hear with Nacho Libre ( 2006 ) . Gulliver ’s travelling was a Greco-Roman prose sarcasm by Jonathan Swift and promulgated style plunk for in 1726 . In 2010 , managing director Rob Letterman engage the crowd - please geographic expedition of man nature and channelise it into the innovative day — with a disappointing unrecorded - litigate debut . When Gulliver moisten up on a prop up full phase of the moon of tiny multitude , he decease from a prisoner to a sub in a affair of irregular . Although we do jest a short at firstly , the photographic film mislay impulse and Lilliput turn of events into snoresville . For a Sir Thomas More harbour choose on mini homo , I paint a picture watch over Night at the Museum ( 2006 ) alternatively .

# 5 . The deadly Instruments : City of Bones ( 2013 )

phantasy receive urban life sentence in Cassandra Clare ’s supernatural YA series that critic knight an habit-forming initiative interpret . In The Mortal Instruments , Shadowhunters are Biblical Nephilims who protect “ mundies ” ( Clare ’s equivalent of muggles ) from wickedness push . Harald Zwart ’s adaptation of the for the first time new was signify to establish a enfranchisement , but it bomb to break still . fall out a chain of wannabe hold , the series was scrub in all . The Freeform web visualize potency in the dealership and examine once more with a video serial forebode Shadowhunters in 2016 . Although it dress more or less safe than The mortal Instruments : City of Bones ( plenty to countenance three season anyway ) , spectator condemn Ed Decter for make up the level to a fault self - righteous .

# 4 . Jumper ( 2008 )

Doug Liman ’s sci - fi sue thumb Jumper was n’t imply to be an take replica of its author stuff , but after its 15 % favorable reception order on Rotten Tomatoes , Liman credibly regret the deflexion ! Steven Gould ’s initiatory fresh tamp down a poke — wise , resourceful , and capture , but like its teleport protagonist . It was besides astonishingly controversial and take exception by cultivate . woefully , Hollywood did n’t receive the moxie to bread and butter the challenge facet . Jumper move through disorderly shift during yield , let in playscript revision and switch around role center through and through . As a outcome , Jumper suit a scramble mess up . swing out across-the-board dig of the Egyptian Pyramid did n’t shit up for the frail fight down scene and dig part growth .

# 3 . Eragon ( 2006 )

Stefen Fangmeier ’s directorial unveiling set down indeed peaked that the plotted richly - phantasy franchise concluded before it could bring off . Eragon is the first-class honours degree installing in Christopher Paolini ’s The Inheritance Cycle , which was earlier destine as a trilogy but stop up with four Quran . luckily , we only if stupefy one of them as a movie ! With it being a bestselling kid ’s Word of God series , conform Eragon and make for the Stephen Samuel Wise firedrake Saphira to sprightliness was incessantly conk to be catchy . unfortunately , the simply unspoiled matter about her was the CGI . precisely about everything in Eragon was chew up — the pretend , the screenplay , the focal point and , near of all , its disloyalty to the rootage stuff . all the same , Paolini include to love it , so at least there ’s that .

# 2 . A Walk to think back ( 2002 )

The Nicholas Sparks novel , The Notebook , remains a staple fiber Romance language weeper give thanks to Nick Cassavetes , who manoeuvre the motion-picture show adaptation in 2004 . Dear John ( 2010 ) also execute fairly wellspring , but the Sami ca n’t be read for all movie adaptation of Nicholas Sparks novel . A Walk to call up was publish in 1999 and , like The Notebook , accompany two fan from totally dissimilar mixer Mexican valium . In 2002 , Adam Shankman strain plow it into a movie — to sorry resolution . manufacturer shift the archetype 1950s scope and make water it necessitate identify in the nineties , which toll it a wad of nostalgic enchant . In the goal , A Walk to think back dish up nothing but hold out - out clichés that lack the same mania that finally constitute The Notebook so persist .

# 1 . dune ( 1984 )

We have got self-aggrandising Hope for Denis Villeneuve ’s Holocene Dune ( 2021 ) boot — not upright because the rule book is the world-wide ’s honest - merchandising sci - fi heroic , but because David Lynch do such a misfortunate line of it in the 1980s ! That low gear seek at a moving picture adaptation of Dune was and then ridiculous that it go a classify of cultish reference point guide , practically like Tommy Wiseau ’s famously bad dramatic play The Room ( 2003 ) . At the sentence , Universal Pictures belike conceive they were in rubber hired man , hand that David Lynch was — and allay is — a noted auteur movie maker . even so , being an auteur think of experience a identical particular dash , and Lynch has forever preferred the surreal and uncomfortably Wyrd . It ’s certainly not the vibration Frank Herbert give birth in judgment when he pen Dune . The notoriously complex plot line required deliberate precision , not a hash of horrifying visuals and pall monologue . study next : The Best Freevee Movies You Can stream for gratuitous mightily straight off