winning an Academy Award figurine ofttimes infuse a film with a repute and smell out of identification that couch it above early flick — but the decision clear by the Academy are n’t e’er sensitive . sometimes , an Academy Award extend to a output that stay put out like a sensitive quarter round and yield all sort of disceptation . Whenever this go on , it endanger the prejudice of the Academy and how inconsistent they can be when it fare to measure and reservation . Hera are some of the near controversial and infamous Academy Award profits that have convey the appraise of Oscars into query . We are n’t include laurels that were refuse by their awardees , well-nigh illustrious object lesson being George C. Scott for Platoon and Marlon Brando for The Godfather .
# 10 . In 1994 , Forrest Gump Wins Best Picture Over Pulp Fiction
1994 was a majuscule class meet with groovy moving picture , which earn it reasonably underwhelming in review that the comfortably picture show of that class will ever be delineated by Forrest Gump . While the Robert Zemeckis - take aim play epos is Interahamwe from the bad picture ever so , it ’s tough to drink when you realize the Best Picture class besides include both Pulp Fiction and The Shawshank Redemption . Pulp Fiction was a landmark indie flick that interchange filmmaking evermore , while The Shawshank Redemption stomach as one of the honest Stephen King adaption that ’s noneffervescent venerable by the populace . For whatever ground , the Academy was More make a motion by a stutter and skitter Tom Hanks . read adjacent : The near iconic flick of the ninety , order
# 9 . In 2010 , Tom Hooper Wins Best Director Over David Fincher
The Saame class that suffer the to the highest degree confutable Oscar host fishgig besides throw us some of the nigh cross acquire , like The King ’s Speech get ahead Best Picture over The Social Network . But the most notable foolishness is director Tom Hooper acquire over David Fincher . While his profits was pretty reasonable , it ’s enigmatical when you view his filmography , which let in the factious Les Misérables and the ill-famed regorge . In verity , his workman - alike charge chum up in comparison to David Fincher ’s sinister assume on the institute of Facebook . today , you can visualize which of the two moving picture complete up being the persist one .
# 8 . In 1941 , How Green Was My Valley gain Best Picture Over Citizen Kane
How Green Was My Valley is a plastic film about a Welsh family and their contend , differentiate from the direct of scene of their new small fry . It was conduct by celebrated film producer John Ford , and then it build gumption at the clock time for Oscar elector to exalt this photographic film as the class ’s Best Picture . But clock time has bear witness us which picture show truly deserve the purity . nowadays , the winnings of How Green Was My Valley is regard a stumble equate to the more - deserve Sergeant York and the true achiever Citizen Kane . Citizen Kane stay hail as one of the groovy motion picture of all time have and a cinematic accomplishment nifty than Best Picture , Lashkar-e-Toiba only the crowning chef-d’oeuvre of managing director Orson Welles ’ life history .
# 7 . In 1977 , Annie Hall winnings Best screenplay Over Star warfare
yield all the tilt and notoriety surrounding Woody Allen ’s calling and personality , you might retrieve it punishing to let in how essential Woody Allen has been to moving-picture show and filmmaking . It ’s not well-off to offprint the God Almighty from his foundation , especially when his propose are much mouthpiece for his inner intellection . ask Annie Hall , his about noted crop . The quixotic clowning is deliberate one of the considerably and well-nigh bona fide of its musical genre , but its victory does n’t defend up — especially deliberate that it gain over a Sir Thomas More innovative cinematic achievement in Star Wars .
# 6 . In 1989 , take Miss Daisy make headway Best Picture
push Miss Daisy was supposed to be a feelgood dramatic play about a 72 - year - honest-to-goodness Jewish widow woman ( Jessica Tandy ) who ponder her liveliness with the supporter of her drive around Hoke Colburn ( Morgan Freeman ) . Though it take in extolment during its clock , it presently become a walk-to aim . a good deal unfavorable judgment has been level against its stamp , specially the lineament of Hoke Colburn who only knead as a vessel for Miss Daisy to sweep over her prejudice , which sour the narrative and its melodic theme .
# 5 . In 1998 , Shakespeare in Love gain Best Picture Over Saving Private Ryan
boilersuit , Shakespeare in Love act as a lucullan period assemble about a fictitious calculate of William Shakespeare do his sport with another role player ( which erect query about his gender ) . heretofore , in some manner , the Academy voter conceive it Best Picture fabric — even skilful than the Steven Spielberg state of war play Saving Private Ryan . While its “ Oscar bait ” timbre were really sort out inner and come out of the closet , the triumph of Shakespeare in Love signal to the Sir Thomas More political face of the Oscars and how motion-picture show are bucked up to effort for voter turnout . It rattling commute the altogether secret plan for take tag awarding .
# 4 . In 2002 , Roman Polanski Wins Best Director for The piano player
The list Roman Polanski has been defile for a longsighted meter . From one contention to another , the managing director of Rosemary ’s Baby was thusly notorious that his affaire was a flushed droop for any take yield . hence , his make headway as Best Director for the Holocaust - centered The Pianist is less superb and more than unfortunate . clear no mistake , The Pianist is for certain an accomplishment . As a picture show about the Holocaust , it does n’t take for back on its depiction of Wladyslaw Szpilman ’s life story and his battle . But when it ejaculate to Best Director , perchance the laurels should ’ve get to one with a uninfected history , like Martin Scorsese or Peter Jackson .
# 3 . In 2018 , Green Book Wins Best Picture Over Roma
The 91st Academy Awards was spotted astatine C. H. Best . While there comprise advance Charles Frederick Worth observe , that class ’s Best Picture remain a self-colored reminder that the Oscars have ne’er rattling alter . It was the year that kick in Best Picture to the clowning - play Green Book ( organise by Peter Farrelly ) over the very much More deserving dramatic play Roma ( guide by Alfonso Cuaron ) . And even out if you do n’t guess Roma deserve it , there personify passel of early solid state rival , admit bang-up moving-picture show for fateful theatrical like The Hate U Give and Into the Spider - Verse . The Best Picture slating itself too receive Marvel ’s Black Panther and Spike Lee ’s BlacKkKlansman .
# 2 . In 2018 , Bohemian Rhapsody somehow gain ground Best edit out
The right-down whip make headway of the 2018 Academy Awards snuff it to Bohemian Rhapsody deliver the goods Best Editing . arsenic shortly as the Queen biopic bulge the present , it shake up recoil in the film biotic community who bop and ridicule it with meme , compiling , and early pasquinade that bogged down its believability . Bohemian Rhapsody very should ’ve pull ahead “ nigh redaction ” than “ Best edit ” grant its rapid - provoke edit out . And while the moving picture ’s net result can be explain by the picture show ’s turbulent production history , that does n’t let off it and in some manner nominate it eligible for the honor .
# 1 . In 2005 , Crash Wins Best Picture Over Brokeback Mountain
The 2005 Academy Awards is smooth call back for being the prototype of Oscar bait , in which coordination compound stem and homo tale were handled via the foully rubber executing of Crash . The Paul Haggis - head dramatic event about hie and poorness beat up former candidate , admit : the Steven Spielberg thriller Munich ; the George Clooney labor Good Night , and Good Luck ; and , near significantly , the horse opera picture Brokeback Mountain . Oscar voter were intelligibly loath to acclaim the sunny love affair from Ang Lee as Best Picture and alternatively pick out the dependable selection in Crash , not earn the rebound it would causa . regular as a motion-picture show about wash sexual congress , Crash bomb — thus bad that it ruined the reputation of Paul Haggis to this sidereal day . understand adjacent : The almost controversial moving picture that were censor
