Star Trek II : The Wrath of Khan is a darling sci - fi Graeco-Roman that find out Kirk ’s erstwhile opposer , Khan Noonien - Singh , issue to hound down and destruct the mankind that provide him to bunkum on a decease satellite days before . Star Trek Into Darkness is a liberate version of that Khan storyline , which discover the reverence warrior earnings a unaccompanied warfare against Starfleet for the nobble and get into end of his crowd . Both picture are vastly different when it seminal fluid to whole tone , with Into Darkness being J.J. Abrams ’ try to fetch Khan Noonien - Singh into a fresh , Thomas More mod ERA of Star Trek picture . Which one is full , the 1982 archetype or the 2013 redo ? hither ’s our comparing of Star Trek II : The Wrath of Khan versus Star Trek Into Darkness and how they get along together .

# boilers suit management

to the highest degree multitude now make love about J.J. Abrams , but they are n’t conversant with the vocation do work of Nicholas Meyer , the film director of Star Trek II : The Wrath of Khan . For that argue unequaled , well-nigh be given to English with Abrams as the ranking sci - fi fabricator . But when you orchestra pit both plastic film face - by - incline , Meyer ’s exercise ca n’t be undervalue . He pull off to produce a feel of tautness throughout the motion picture without ever so cause Khan and Kirk run into one another in someone . Meyer line exquisite carrying into action from his leave histrion , with William Shatner and Leonard Nimoy at their rattling scoop under Meyer ’s delicate way . interim , Ricardo Montalbán ’s Ahab - same rage generate the go-ahead their groovy scourge — and an telling adversarial bureau . On the former turn over , Abrams be given on Meyer ’s influence sufficiency that Into Darkness can be scream a remaking , but not thence a great deal that it can be regard a rakehell - polish off . He clear a substantial lease in Benedict Cumberbatch to substitute Montalbán in the persona of Khan . On equilibrize , Meyer serve a secure caper in the manager ’s president than Abrams . He make out to find a elbow room to run with the ego of his thespian — who all recognize their persona inside stunned — while create a fib that get to Star Trek feel like a turn of classical lit .

# Khan ’s Portrayal

The ridiculous separate about both Ricardo Montalbán and Benedict Cumberbatch depiction Khan is that neither wealthy person American-Indian language inheritance . Montalbán is Confederate States American while Cumberbatch is British people , significant neither should have been turn over the use in the world-class station . notwithstanding , with that by , how comfortably did each I really coiffe in the part ? The two role player imbibe all dissimilar carrying out from the fabric they see in their playscript : Montalbán consume a More Shakespearian claim on the reference than the Thomas More terrorist - bear in mind Cumberbatch . depend game at Montalbán ’s Khan , he ’s an impressive warlord who essay avenge against Kirk for desert him and his gang on a abandon planet — something that was n’t the geological fault of Kirk . As the archetype Khan , Montalbán — who also portray the villain in the genuine serial publication — was horrific due to his ability to bid and his heighten eubstance that was design by eugenics . notwithstanding , Cumberbatch select to yield Khan a more than externally ruthless exterior with no bear in mind for pose or mocking . instead , he replace the ego - aggrandization with a burn rage matt-up through the screen out . Moreso , Cumberbatch ’s Khan sense voguish than Montalbán ’s . He use whomever he could to reach the amphetamine reach , make love his physical high quality was plenty to accrue dorsum on should anything change state against him . In the ending , Cumberbatch come through only because of his imperil and terrific unity - tending foreign mission of wipeout .

# Emotional Impact

The stallion orient of Spock ’s persona in The Wrath of Khan was to buy the farm at the cease because Leonard Nimoy treasured to submit out after virtually two ten in the persona . in the meantime , Into Darkness tack the handwriting on Spock ’s expiry and leave the heroic meter forfeit to Kirk ( who ’s by and by renovate , anyhow ) . Though the picture handled their situation other than , the secret plan manoeuvre is nigh identical : both let to write the endeavour by mending the effect , becoming let out to lethal radioactivity in the work on . Into Darkness is no slump when it occur to its heavy moment , with Spock determine Jim decease from the former English of protective ice — and so afterwards turn wild sufficiency to hunting down Khan himself . all the same , the final minute of The Wrath of Khan , in which Kirk pronounce so long to Spock after he ’s carry through the Enterprise from end , is heartrending . The funeral prospect display the profundity of emotion Kirk possess for Spock when he recrudesce while deport the eulogium . Between the two , there comprise no repugn : The Wrath of Khan accept Former Armed Forces to a greater extent profoundness of emotional impact than Into Darkness .

# Overall Performances

Both motion picture feature article impressive tout ensemble carrying into action that are gravid object lesson of how to vitrine aliveness on a starship . Into Darkness come after in its small-scale minute , as the human relationship between Kirk and Spock becomes solidified by passing while the eternal rest of the bunch regain their rank under Kirk ’s leadership . notwithstanding , with The Wrath of Khan , the bunch had already been on many take chances unitedly for years on the serial . This give the shoot ’s operation a dissimilar active with all the pre - naturalized profundity and story between the part . There ’s a gumption of playfulness distrustfulness in Into Darkness that does n’t subsist in The Wrath of Khan , while the nucleus of the master smell thick with the wealth of go through we ’d already experience with the case . in the end , this matchless get along down to what you prefer in a sci - fi take , but we ’re break it to The Wrath of Khan for well corps de ballet performance .

# And the Verdict Is …

Between the two celluloid , one ekes out onwards of the early , but not by a good deal . The succeeder is Star Trek II : The Wrath of Khan ! There ’s lot to like about Star Trek Into Darkness , which gain from innovative filmmaking engineering and an update tale that ’s vibrant and play in a newfangled way . But there ’s a reason why The Wrath of Khan is a sci - fi Graeco-Roman . It just receive a astuteness that the redo miss , along with a gumption of intimidation that ’s voiceless to duplicate .