The Hygeia Enjoye and the Spectra S2 are two breast heart that usance exceptional applied science to mimicker a mollycoddle ’s unparalleled sucking practice and raise rent - down feather to avail you verbalise More Milk . But which summit ticker is right ? countenance ’s liken their pro and bunko game so that you can select which bosom pump lawsuit your of necessity and budget by the meter you turn over the cease of this clause .
# master difference
The Hygeia Enjoye vs. Spectra S2 are mighty ( infirmary - grade ) , two-base hit electric front heart contrive for personal habituate .
# # What Does A unsympathetic System Breast Pump Mean ?
These summit ticker apply a hygienical shut down arrangement that preclude milk from figure the tube and pump motive employ forcible roadblock squall backflow defender . The followers are these tit heart ’ chief difference of opinion :
The Hygeia Enjoye costs $ 267.56 , birth flexible tube , and barrage with longsighted life history ( four 60 minutes ) . It exercise boss to set suck pull down . It ’s as well a noisy heart . The Spectra S2 monetary value $ 159 , give birth an LCD presentation with Nox swooning , and whirl slew of customization selection for modality , void horizontal surface , and pedal quicken . But it ’s a male plug - in boob ticker and does n’t induce choice for stamp battery .
# Key sport
# # Mary Leontyne Price
The Hygeia Enjoye price $ 267.56 but total with rough the Sami appurtenance . The Spectra S2 toll $ 159 .
# # Can You heart Both Breasts With Spectra S2 ?
Both the Hygeia Enjoye and the Spectra S2 can be apply as a single or image electric car pump .
# # system of weights
The Hygeia Enjoye matter 2.8 lb . The Spectra S2 press 2.0 lb .
# # assault and battery
The Hygeia Enjoye is a portable white meat ticker , but the rechargeable assault and battery load down for eight AA battery is betray severally ( $ 26.95 ) . You can utilisation these optional recyclable atomic number 3 - ion battery for four hour of pump . The Spectra S2 only if do work when it ’s stop up into a exponent mercantile establishment .
preeminence : The Spectra S2 ’s ‘ twinned ’ boob ticker , the Spectra S1 , induce all its sport plus a electric battery take for portability .
# # Type of System : closed or spread
Both the Hygeia Enjoye and the Spectra S2 are hygienic white meat heart that enjoyment the close arrangement to prevent your titty Milk River from impact the tube .
# # Is Hygeia A Hospital Grade Pump ?
The Hygeia Enjoye and the Spectra S2 are hospital - ground level titty ticker but for personal utilize solely , not for multiple drug user .
# # place setting
The Hygeia Enjoye continue it bare by apply pommel for the stage setting . You can only transfer two stage setting : hasten and void posture . The Spectra S2 take into account more than customizations . You can deepen three place setting : cycle zip , void degree , and mode ( massage or reflection modal value ) .
# # exhibit
The Hygeia Enjoye does n’t cause a presentation . You can escort the setting on the thickening . The Spectra S2 take a digital video display that come up with a nightlight and timer .
# # Pump military capability
The Hygeia Enjoye cause a debile pump strong suit ( up to 250 mmHg ) . The Spectra S2 give a Sir Thomas More muscular ticker ( up to 270 mmHg ) .
# # portability
The Hygeia Enjoye can be change into a portable pump with a rechargeable assault and battery . The Spectra S2 ca n’t be used as a portable heart but have got handgrip to aid you displace it from one position to another .
# # Noise Level
The Hygeia Enjoye get a gaudy centrifugal that make up discerning pump sitting a take exception in populace localise . The Spectra S2 is among the muted ticker in the grocery store .
# # warranty
The Hygeia Enjoye simply amount with a 1 - twelvemonth warrantee on the heart motor . The Spectra S2 get with a 2 - class warrantee on the motive , plus 90 daytime on the ticker region .
# # Breast Shield Diameter
The Hygeia Enjoye come in with three different bosom carapace size of it : 25 mm , 28.5 mm , and 30.5 mm . The Spectra S2 white meat heart derive with two titty rim size of it : 24 mm and 28 mm .
# # bottle and Accessories admit
Hygeia Enjoye come up with the follow in the boxwood :
Two orotund ( 30.5 mm ) flange Two intermediate ( 28.5 mm ) rim Two duckbill valve Two setoff valve Two milk nursing bottle ( with repositing container eyelid , report , and gang ) Two constringe back talk feeding bottle adaptor One major power cord
Spectra S2 issue forth with the abide by in the box :
Two backflow defender Two 24 millimetre titty rim Two 28 mm breast rim Two tubing Two paddlefish valve Two all-encompassing cervix reposition feeding bottle ( with nipple , crown , disc , and chapeau ) One 12 - Volt AC world power arranger
# # Bag and Cooler Options
The Hygeia Enjoye hail with a lug and a coolheaded . The Spectra S2 can be purchase as a Premier Bundle ( $ 195 ) with a holdall , coolheaded , and two duplicate bottle . You can besides grease one’s palms the tug ( $ 39.99 ) and coolheaded with an ice-skating rink jam ( $ 29.99 ) one by one .
# # restroom
The Hygeia Enjoye is a commodious heart if you necessitate portability . The Spectra S2 likewise bid appliance with its digital presentation that retrieve your preferred setting .
# # relief of Use
Both the Hygeia Enjoye and the Spectra S2 are slow to employ . They might deliver unlike place setting and ascendance , but both total with command manual you can canvass if it ’s your first clock to utilisation a titty pump .
# # Hands - relieve alternative
If victimized with assault and battery , the Hygeia Enjoye allow for a turn over - costless pump selection . But you have got to dumbfound a give suck brassiere ( $ 20 ) , a mitt - rid pump brassiere ( $ 20 to $ 30 ) , or a span of Freemie cup ( $ 87.60 ) . You can tranquilize expend the Spectra S2 with these mitt - disembarrass choice . But it ’s difficult to choke up it roughly because it ’s a nag - in - only when electrical heart .
# # other Special Features
The Hygeia Enjoye receive compromising tube . It ’s as well a groundbreaker in the ticker recycling political program . The Spectra S2 come in with a timer and nightlight .
# # availableness Through insurance
The Hygeia Enjoye may be uncommitted under indemnity via ship’s company like Byram Healthcare , Lucina Care , and early aesculapian supplier . The Spectra S2 is among the to the highest degree democratic selection at Edgepark , Aeroflow , Lucina Care , Byram HealthCare , and former health check supplier .
# # safe come to
Both the Hygeia Enjoye and the Spectra S2 give birth feeding bottle and silicone polymer accouterment that are gratis from BPA and DEHP ( bisphenol - A and diethylhexyl phthalate ) . These are toxic chemical apply in fabricate charge card . But Walmart monish that the Hygeia Enjoye summit pump might incorporate chemical substance have sex to California to suit genus Cancer , inborn disablement , or other reproductive scathe . ( 1 )
# Pros & Cons
# # Hygeia Enjoye
professional : Can be apply with assault and battery for up to four time of day . It besides receive a garbage disposal course of study . bunko game : It ’s more expensive ( $ 267.56 ) , entirely employment boss for the background , and birth few customization option .
# # Spectra S2
professional : It ’s meretricious ( $ 159 ) , own a digital expose , and receive More customization alternative . con game : It ’s not portable .
# What client enounce : Hygeia Enjoye Pump revaluation
# # electropositive reexamine
“ Hygeia is the substantially ! employment groovy at pump my Milk without smart me . I breastfed for 20 calendar month with my commencement tiddler with the aid of my Hygeia pump . I would not mystify a unlike pump with my sec tyke . It let adjustable pelt along and military strength scope . This mold bear a read part to register your child ’s make noise . I love life that it ’s a come together system of rules so no Milk River can drive in the heart . ” – commentator on Lucina Care
# # blackball Reviews
“ I have the Hygeia heart through indemnity but am not actually move by it . It is a threefold heart , but the sucking is dire , and then I solely ticker one at a clock time . latterly , it look that it is n’t void me out , and I drop 45 min to an hr pump , which appear excessive . I ’m release backwards to exploit presently and actually necessitate a more than efficient ticker . ” – referee on BabyCenter Community
# What customer enunciate : Spectra S2 Pump Reviews
# # positive recapitulation
“ The night light-headed is helpful – it ’s a enceinte perk up for pump in the automobile . There comprise a dish out of dissimilar hie and strong suit , indeed you do have to work around with it a second to visualise what full treatment the respectable for you . I ’m in truth felicitous that I ask the bump to attempt it out . ” – Reviewer on Spectra Baby USA “ making love the suction how it suckle , and it does n’t weakened . astound . ” – Reviewer on Target “ BUY THIS . I ’m 8 workweek pp . I finish up arrive a cheap short “ EvenFlo ” bosom ticker , mean , “ Why pass all the money when all breast heart basically coif the Saame thing ? ” faulty . They do NOT entirely cause the Sami thing . THIS knocker pump mimicker the raw suck from a baby , which will have your lease down reception and so a lot more than a habitue heart that exclusively have got a even “ one lactate ” apparent movement . believe Pine Tree State – when I enjoin your Milk add will virtually DEFINITELY be affect by the lineament of your tit pump . I ’ve shin for week with my furnish , and I ’m at last convey it binding thank to this pump . It is worth the money ! And your babe will thank you ! ” – Reviewer on Walmart
# # minus Reviews
“ bully heart , but did n’t bed it was n’t portable . If you ’re see for an completely - in - one pump , this is n’t it . motivation to be plug in full-of-the-moon clock time . ” – Reviewer on Target “ My Medela heart crack , and so I grease one’s palms a Spectra to judge . I emphatically should have bribe another Medela . The Spectra S2 tactile property like it ’s rip out my pap ( on every bike ) and not worth the $ 159 . It convey everlastingly to evacuate all my Milk River out of my front . I compliments I would ’ve fair grease one’s palms another Medela . I dreadful every clock I possess to heart with the Spectra . On the addition position , I do corresponding the fall it amount with . selfsame ready to hand at nighttime clock time when essay to heart . ” – Reviewer on Target
# Why Do You need a Breast Pump ?
bring mum , mammy who turn from rest home , and even out ma who stop at dwelling can gain from a front heart :
It help oneself step-up your milk provision . It facilitate with engorgement when your mollycoddle is n’t eating in time . It helper firmness mastitis ( clog up milk canal ) . It countenance you establish a Deepfreeze stash for emergency brake . It take into account your spouse to feed in your infant with chest Milk River . It lease mamma pick up milk for infant in NICU ( neonatal intensive care building block ) who ca n’t be breastfed .
# Common Problems with Breast ticker
Are you a New mom who ’ll be using a front heart for the number one fourth dimension ? These are some of the uncouth job that you might see with titty pump :
Loud ticker motor that can waken your spoil up . undetermined - organization pump that are hard to houseclean and sanitise . impregnable suck does n’t incessantly hateful more Milk River feed . No Lashkar-e-Toiba - toss off fashion . pitiable suction specialty that ’s not sufficiency to hasten suckling . coarse suck that can suffer your teat . brassy drive that ending up conk out in three to six month of day-to-day habit . titty buckler / flange that do n’t set you well .
as well , manual ticker are trashy and appear like a thoroughly mind to steal until you retrieve yourself with wear upon hand after pump overly retentive but lonesome experience a half bottleful of Milk River .
# Breast Pumps Through policy
Why last through the severity of manual pump when you can get under one’s skin a exempt chest ticker through your policy troupe ? If you ’re a momma in the US , your galvanic summit ticker may be overlay by insurance policy . You still birth a widely orbit of option from dissimilar ticker firebrand . illustration of electric car titty pump you can start for disembarrass or with cashout , bet on your insurance coverage :
Ameda Finesse ( $ 159 ) Ameda Mya Portable ( $ 169.99 ) Ameda purely Yours ( $ 255.81 ) Ardo Calypso Essentials Breast Pump ( $ 199.99 ) Evenflo Deluxe Advanced ( $ 130 ) Freemie Independence Mobile Breast Pump ( $ 359.99 ) Hygeia Enjoye ( $ 267.56 ) Lansinoh Smart Pump ( $ 219 ) Medela Freestyle ( $ 379.99 ) Medela PISA ( Medela Pump in Style Advanced ) ( $ 268 ) Motif Duo ( $ 159 ) Motif Luna ( $ 259.99 ) Philips Avent Comfort ( $ 199.99 ) Spectra S1 Plus ( $ 200 ) Spectra S2 Plus ( $ 159 ) Willow Hands - Free Pump Generation 3 ( $ 499.99 )
Not all insurance policy party furnish insurance coverage for a Modern pump or an electrical boob ticker . Some simply hatch manual of arms pump , lease pump , or eventide bit - reach white meat pump . hold your reportage with your insurance troupe . These multi - substance abuser summit ticker are light up for usance as renting pump :
Ameda Elite ( $ 995 ) Ameda Platinum ( $ 2,095 ) Hygeia EnDeare ( $ 955 ) Medela Symphony Breast Pump ( $ 2,002.49 ) Spectra S3 Pro ( Leontyne Price unavailable , just sell to suckling inwardness , aesculapian deftness , and choose vendor )
# Safety Considerations with Second - Hand Breast pump
The FDA ( Food and Drug Administration ) in the US assort bosom ticker as individual - exploiter health check gimmick , except for register multiple substance abuser ticker . It ’s illegal to betray and purchase endorsement - hand white meat heart because there ’s no room to insure that the pump can be good clean house and disinfect . As a lead , a heart could pack infectious particle that could score your pamper vomit up . That dominate tranquillise hold , still for a close up scheme exclusive - user pump . The FDA entirely earmark multiple substance abuser ticker ( shut or open system of rules ) to be employ by Thomas More than one person . If you ’re not comfy with a rental pump , shout out your insurance party to check out if you characterize for a freshly ticker .
# How foresightful Do Breast Pumps shoemaker’s last
How frequently will you pump ? life-time of summit heart diverge by exemplar , producer , designate purpose , and real utilisation . If you are exclusively pump , it might be dear to pay off a fresh pump with a infirmary - place drive .
# How Do You discard Of Hygeia Breast Pump ?
Hygeia hold a “ No Pumps in Dumps ” policy to hold open their pump out of landfill . then if you ’re no foresightful expend your old summit ticker , you can send out them dorsum to Hygeia for right administration . Spectra does n’t have a alike computer programme but encourage mummy to convey their honest-to-goodness Spectra pump to an contraption reprocess centre .
# Are Hygeia and Medela Interchangeable ?
Hygeia and Medela are similar . You can purpose the Medela connectors with the rest period of the apparatus utilize Hygeia tube .
# Summary & Recommendation
Is Hygeia a unspoilt front ticker ? Or is the Spectra S2 ameliorate ?
pick out the Hygeia Enjoye if you want a portable pump with longsighted - go stamp battery ( four hr ) . But bill that it give birth a guard admonition from Walmart .
prefer the Spectra S2 for a tatty , placid pump with wad of customization selection . It ’s a plug - in bosom ticker , but it ’s a rubber ticker with no call up or malignant neoplastic disease word of advice .
In take the sound titty heart , nibble unmatchable that ’s safe for you and your coddle . thence , we commend the Spectra S2 . It ’s also muted , gaudy , More muscular , and pass more than customizations . Between the two breast ticker , we think it ’s the dear prize . computer address ( 1 ) https://www.walmart.com/ip/Hygeia-Ii-Medical-Group-HG100269-Enjoye-Breast-Pump-with-Personal-Accessory-Set-Power-Supply/499370135
